Frosted Christmas Tree Cookies
A simple cookie recipe that is actually baked more like bars to begin to simplify the process. After it’s baked it is then cut into wedges, or individual cookies, and decorated from there. No chilling dough, no rolling dough and no cookie cutters required. This version is all about being easy. I made these with my kids this weekend for a fun baking project and I thought they were too good not to share. These are unbelievably soft, deliciously buttery, perfectly sweet (once you add the frosting) and they’re simplistically satisfying – yet pretty and festive. Plus the decorating options are endless. I’ve listed the recipe to include a little extra frosting because we know how kids (and some of us adults) like to decorate cookies – extra frosting and loads of sprinkles. If you like sugar cookies or blondies this is the holiday cookie for you!
Christmas Tree Cookie Recipe Ingredients
All-purpose flour: I use unbleached but bleached will work nearly just the same. Baking soda: This gives the cookie some lift and some color. Salt: To help balance the sweetness and bring out the flavors. Granulated sugar: I don’t add a whole lot to the cookie so it’s not overly sweet once frosting is added. You could even cut back to 1/2 cup in the dough. Unsalted butter: You’ll need butter for both the cookie and the frosting. Egg: For a substitute I would try something listed here. Vanilla extract: We’ll add to both the cookie dough and the frosting for great flavor. Almond extract: This is optional. Just use more vanilla if you omit. Powdered sugar: Also known as confectioners sugar. Used to build up and sweeten the frosting. Milk: Added to thin the frosting. I like this frosting to be just barely runny so it’s more smoothly pipe-able. Any fat percentage of milk will work here. Green food coloring, Christmas sprinkles, and pretzel rods: All of these are optional. If you just want to drizzle over a pretty snowy white frosting that would be fun too.
Scroll down for full recipe with amounts and print option.
Tips
After making the recipe several times the only thing I’ve noticed is that getting the baked cookie out of a cake pan as a whole can take some coaxing (it’s doable though) but you may find it nice to just go with a springform pan. Or cut some 3-inch strips attached to the parchment round to assist in removing the cookie as a whole.
How to Make Christmas Tree Cookies
Variations
Use lemon zest to flavor the cookie dough. Then finish with a lemon frosting. Add more vanilla or seeds of a vanilla bean to the cookie dough instead of almond extract. Try mixing in sprinkles at the end of mixing dough. Or add festive, colorful M and M’s. You can also tint the dough green if you’d like, or you can leave all food coloring out and just go with a pretty snowy white frosting.
Can the cookies be frozen?
I recommend freezing the cookie disk then cut and decorate after thawing.
Do cookies stack well?
Frosting does get a crust over on the exterior but not throughout so I don’t recommend stacking these cookies unless you switch to an icing that hardens throughout.
Can I double the recipe?
Yes. If you need more cookies just double the recipe then divide batter in half and press into two cake pans or springform pans.
More Tempting Christmas Cookies to Try
Chocolate Crinkle Cookies Gingerbread Cookies Shortbread Cookies Snowman Sugar Cookies Stained Glass Cookies White Chocolate Dipped Ginger Cookies
